By Michael Shea, CBI, CEPA
If you turn on financial news channels like CNBC, you hear a lot of noise about record SBA lending limits and resilient economic indicators. On social media, self-proclaimed gurus continue to market the idea that anyone can buy a business with minimal money down and easy SBA financing.
However, looking strictly at the actual pulse of Main Street—and recent reports from major SBA lenders—paints a very different picture.
We are entering a period where the lending market is tightening, SBA defaults are ticking up [02:04], and consumer spending at the local level is stalling. If you are preparing to buy, sell, or exit a business in today’s environment, you need to look past the headlines and understand the economic realities reshaping the lower middle and Main Street M&A markets.
The Macro Split: Main Street vs. The Middle Market
A noticeable divide has formed in the current economy:
-
The Middle Market ($5M+ in value): These businesses are generally holding up well [02:24]. They possess stronger balance sheets, deeper operational reserves, and better pricing power to withstand inflationary cycles.
-
Main Street Businesses: Lower-tier small businesses are feeling severe pressure [02:38]. Rising cost of living, persistent inflation, high interest rates, and cautious consumers are forcing flat or declining revenue streams across retail, restaurants, and local services [02:43].
Even retail giants like Publix are reporting flat sales and year-over-year store traffic declines, proving that even upper-middle-income consumers are cutting back and coupon shopping [01:03]. When consumer pullbacks occur at the macro level, small businesses are the first to feel the squeeze.
The SBA Lending Bottleneck
For years, the standard playbook for acquiring a business involved securing an SBA 7(a) loan with 10% down. But as default rates rise, lenders are tightening their underwriting standards [02:10].
SBA underwriters typically look at a company’s three-year historical performance [04:26]. If a business shows a recent downward trend in revenue or shrinking margins:
-
Lenders will decline the loan: Banks will not take on risk if historical cash flow fails to clear debt service coverage ratios with a sufficient safety margin [04:31].
-
Valuations will adjust: A business that cannot be financed through traditional banking channels cannot command historical valuation multiples.
If you are expecting bank financing to fund a business with flat or declining year-over-year earnings, you will hit a wall [05:08].
What Buyers & Sellers Must Do Now
Navigating a tightening credit market requires a shift in strategy for both sides of the deal table. Having worked through similar cycles—including the Great Recession of 2008–2009 [05:17]—here is how buyers and sellers must adapt:
For Business Sellers:
-
Prepare for Seller Financing: Expecting 100% cash at closing via bank debt is becoming unrealistic for many Main Street deals. Sellers must be open to carrying 30% to 50% in seller notes to bridge the gap left by conservative bank underwriting [05:24].
-
Clean Up the Financials: Lenders and buyers are auditing trailing twelve-month (TTM) performance more aggressively than ever.
-
Evaluate Your Timeline: If you have a 3-to-5-year horizon, now is the time to focus on de-risking your operation, strengthening your balance sheet, and building sustainable recurring revenue [06:10]. If you are looking to exit immediately, pricing expectations must reflect current credit market conditions [05:34].
For Business Buyers:
-
Bring Real Equity: The days of low-equity, highly leveraged acquisitions are sunsetting. Buyers need stronger balance sheets and cash reserves [05:08].
-
Focus on Debt Serviceability: High interest rates mean that taking on debt leaves less margin for error. Target businesses with stable cash flows and low operational volatility [04:31].
-
Negotiate Structured Deals: Look to structure transactions with earn-outs, seller notes, or performance-contingent terms to protect against near-term revenue volatility.
Final Thoughts
Economic cycles inevitably shift leverage between buyers and sellers. While credit constriction creates near-term friction, well-prepared sellers who pre-plan their exit strategy and buyers who bring practical capital structures to the table will continue to close successful deals [06:34].
If you have questions about business valuations, SBA deal readiness, or how to structure a transition in today’s market, feel free to reach out to schedule a discussion.